For the board's majority, it was a dollars-and-cents decision to shut down Joe Toler Oak Hill Elementary School and to consolidate Mary Potter Middle School with Northern Granville Middle.
"All of us love these schools," said District 3 Member Rob Rivers who supported the closure and consolidation. "I have lost more sleep over this decision than any decision in my life."
The closure and consolidations are part of the school board's reorganization plan to confront lagging enrollment.
The number of students at Mary Potter Middle has dropped from 464 students in 2009 to 248 this school year. Joe Toler Elementary's enrollment has dropped to 187 students from 229 students 10 years ago.
But the crowd largely rejected the board's argument that it's too expensive to operate these schools.
For Joe Toler parents, it's the only school in the northern end of the county. Their children will now be forced to take an hour-long bus ride to Northern Granville Middle.
"The students that I teach every day have parents who would have to travel 12 to 15 miles for a PTO meeting or for an afternoon agriculture club that meets until 4:30," said Toler Elementary teacher Heather Daniel.
For supporters of Mary Potter Middle, this was a heartbreaking decision. The school was founded in 1889 as a private boarding school to educate newly-freed slaves. It boasts a long list of distinguished alumni including former NAACP President Ben Chavis and former NBA player and coach John Lucas.
The district blames the lagging public school enrollment on the growing number of parents choosing charter schools.
“They sold us down the drain!” —— Joel Brown (@JoelBrownABC11) January 8, 2019
Parents, teachers, and alumni walk out in protest of Granville County School Board decision to close and consolidate two historically black community schools. #abc11 pic.twitter.com/3jCWPMjeOa
"All these other schools that are taking kids away from the public schools, that's what is going on. They have home schools, charter schools - we need to keep that money in the public schools," said Rosalyn Green, president of the National Mary Potter Club Inc.. Green is also a Mary Potter alumnus.
School board members also voted to study a plan to convert Mary Potter Middle into the school system's central office complex. That did little to soothe the hard feelings about the closures.
"They sold us down the drain. They're not going to do what they say they're going to do. They're just putting us off. They sold us down the drain," said Mary Potter alumnus Eddie McCoy.
Community members are pushing for Durham State Sen. Floyd McKissick to help get Mary Potter School added to the National Registry of Historic Places. But even if that happens, it doesn't stop the plan to shut down the facility as an operational school.