'Outrageous & politicized': California couple seen defacing BLM mural pleads not guilty to hate crime charge

ByAmy Hollyfield via KGO logo
Wednesday, August 5, 2020
EMBED <>More Videos

The two Martinez residents charged for three misdemeanor charges after they were caught on video defacing a Black lives Matter mural plead not guilty in court. Nicole Anderson and David Nelson's attorney calls the charges outrageous and politicized.

MARTINEZ, Calif. -- The California couple accused of a hate crime for painting over a Black Lives Matter mural appeared in court Tuesday.

Nicole Anderson and David Nelson entered not guilty pleas to three misdemeanor charges. Their attorney calls the charges "outrageous and politicized."

"Just as peaceful protesters have the right to march and display their political views in a myriad of different ways, they have the same right to display their dissatisfaction and disagreement with their tax dollars being used to sponsor a radical organization, Black Lives Matter," defense attorney Bill Essayli said outside the courthouse.

WATCH: Video shows confrontation between artists, pair painting over BLM mural in Martinez

A bystander who was looking at the mural on July 4 captured video of the couple pouring black paint on it. The couple did not comment Tuesday but stood next to their attorney as he explained that they did this to protest the city's support of the Black Lives Matter message.

"It is a problem when you have elected officials using tax dollars to politicize an issue and now you have a District Attorney who is making it a crime to disagree with a political message and that's a real problem," Essayli said. "We cannot have two standards of justice in our country. We are thankful we are going to have our day in court."

District Attorney Diana Becton did not comment Tuesday but has showed her support for the mural, calling it a peaceful and powerful way to communicate the importance of Black lives in Contra Costa County.

Mayor Rob Schroder has also expressed his support for the mural.

WATCH: Nike's viral 'You Can't Stop Us' ad is winning big on social media

"Had she just charged vandalism, that would be a whole different issue. The fact that she charged them with vandalism and a hate crime is really what makes this problematic. It's a reach, it's an overcharge, in our view it's a political message and the justice system should not be weaponized in that manner," Essayli said about Becton.

The couple is due back in court in October.