Convicted killers in millionaire's love triangle murder case maintain innocence

Watch the latest episode of "20/20," "The Millionaire's Mistake," now streaming on Hulu.

ByMatt Gutman, Scott Engel, Andrew Paparella, Brooke Stangel and, Sunny Antrim, and Lauren Effron ABCNews logo
Saturday, September 25, 2021
Convicted killers in love triangle murder case maintain innocence
Convicted killer Eric Naposki insists there's "not a chance" he murdered Bill McLaughlin.

NEWPORT BEACH, Calif. -- Nanette Packard, who was convicted of directing her ex-NFL lover to kill her millionaire fiance, told ABC News in an exclusive interview that she still carries "a lot of guilt over what happened."

"Had I not been having an affair ... Bill would be alive still," Packard said. "I feel that way."

Nanette Packard spoke to ABC News in June 2021.

She and former NFL linebacker Eric Naposki have spent nearly a decade behind bars as convicted killers serving life sentences without the possibility of parole for the murder of Bill McLaughlin. Both deny having any involvement in his death.

"I don't know for sure [who killed McLaughlin]," Packard said. "I never said that Eric did it because I couldn't say that Eric did it for sure. I don't know that. He never said that to me."

Watch the full story on the latest episode of "20/20," now streaming on Hulu.

Packard met Naposki in the early '90s at a gym. Naposki, who had once played for the New England Patriots and Indianapolis Colts, had left professional sports by then, and was living in California, where he worked as a security guard for a nightclub and worked as a bodyguard on the side.

Eric Naposki, 91 of the Barcelona Dragons, moves during play of the Trans-Atlantic World League of American football game, March 24, 1991, in Barcelona.

The two eventually started seeing each other romantically even though Packard, who was then a mother of two in her 20s, was already in a relationship with McLaughlin. He was an entrepreneur 30 years her senior who had made millions off of a medical device invention.

Packard was living with McLaughlin in Newport Beach, California, in a luxurious home located in a wealthy, gated community. However, she told Naposki that she and McLaughlin were just business partners.

"Eric knew about Bill and Bill knew that Eric was my friend. [Bill] didn't know we were having an affair," Packard said.

Bill McLaughlin and Nanette Packard pictured in Hawaii.

She said she met McLaughlin, a father of three, through a personal ad he had posted in the Pennysaver.

"Maybe it wasn't the most intense [relationship] romantically but I did love him," Packard said of McLaughlin. "He was a good man and he was good to my children, and I would never have killed him and probably would still be with him today if he were alive, because I had no reason."

Bill McLaughlin pictured with Nanette Packard.

McLaughlin was 55 years old when he was shot six times in the chest by an intruder while he sat at his kitchen table on Dec. 15, 1994.

Authorities did not make any arrests in connection to his death until 15 years later, when investigators re-examined the case.

Packard and Naposki were arrested separately during a bicoastal sting operation in May 2009 on murder charges.

By the time of their arrests, Packard and Naposki had gone their separate ways. Packard had gone on to marry twice more and was still living in California. Naposki, meanwhile, had briefly gone back to playing professional American football overseas before returning to the U.S., where he had a fiancée and was living in Connecticut.

The prosecutor alleged Packard was the suspected mastermind behind McLaughlin's death and that she convinced Naposki to kill him so they could collect a substantial sum of money.

Prosecutors argued that Packard stood to benefit from McLaughlin's million-dollar life insurance policy, $150,000 from his will and access to his beach house.

Bill McLaughlin pictured in a business meeting.

There was reason to suspect Packard. In 1996, she had pleaded guilty to forgery and grand theft after she was accused of forging McLaughlin's name on checks and stealing from his accounts. She served 180 days behind bars.

Packard denied the murder charges against her, saying she needed McLaughlin to continue her lifestyle.

"I only gained money if Bill was alive," she said.

According to prosecutors, Naposki's story evolved during questioning. He initially lied about owning a .9 mm handgun, which was the same kind of weapon used to kill McLaughlin.

"The single most important piece of evidence that we had against Eric Naposki was ... the way he lied to the police," said ABC News consultant and former Orange County prosecutor Matt Murphy, who tried the case.

Defendant Eric Naposki listens as Deputy District Attorney Matt Murphy offers his closing statements during Naposki's murder trial in Santa Ana, Calif., July 12, 2011.

When asked why he lied to police, Naposki told ABC News, "I just didn't want to talk about it because, if I wasn't at the scene, and I wasn't in Newport, then I couldn't have killed the guy even if I had a bazooka."

Naposki went to trial first and was found guilty of first-degree murder in 2011. Afterward, he met with prosecutors and told them Packard had orchestrated a murder-for-hire plot against McLaughlin, and the killer had used his gun.

"[Naposki said] he was there, in the room, when they talked about [the plot],'" said author Caitlin Rother, who wrote a book about the case titled, "I'll Take Care of You." "But then he says, 'But apparently, [the killer] went behind my back and made arrangements with Nanette. So the two of them planned this. It wasn't me.'"

"The way he describes it, he is a co-conspirator in a murder case," Murphy added. "Even if it was true, the way he describes that, he is still 100% guilty for exactly what he was convicted of."

Packard was found guilty in January 2012 of first-degree murder and guilty of the special circumstance of committing murder for financial gain.

Naposki is serving time at Avenal State Prison in Avenal, California. He said he hasn't spoken to Packard since everything "went down."

"I didn't kill anybody. I'm not a killer," he said.

Nanette Johnston waits for opening statements to begin in her trial in Santa Ana, Calif., Jan. 9, 2012.

Packard is serving her sentence at the Central California Women's Facility, training service dogs through a program called Little Angels.

"These dogs, they just bring so much healing," she said. "It also helps to make a difference for me, for me to be able to live with the fact that I'm away from my kids."

This image projected on a court room monitor shows the family of slain millionaire William McLaughlin during former NFL player Eric Naposki's murder trial, June 30, 2011, in Orange County Superior Court in Santa Ana, Calif.

"[Packard and Naposki's lives] have been taken away from them ... and hopefully they're thinking about what they did," Kim McLaughlin told ABC News. "What I miss most about my father is just having him as a friend ... and I know he'd be very proud of us and the choices we're making. And so, it's hard not to have him be able to share that here on earth with him... We miss him dearly."