The shooting happened around 1:40 a.m. in the parking lot of the bar at 115 Turner Street.
The victims were identified as Maurice Donnell White, 31, Curtis Lee Stubbs Jr., 22, Derrikes Lamonte McRae, 38, Jacore Rayshad McKoy, 22, and Lee Marvin Harris Jr., 28.
Police said White died Thursday morning.
Investigators said the shooting victims have not been helpful about giving them information that would help them solve the case.
They're asking witnesses and bar patrons who were there that night to contact the Southern Pines Police Department at (910) 693-1481 or the Crime Tip Line at (910) 693-4110.