"We're not saying this is not going to be the site. We just asked for them, let's put it on pause for a minute," explained member-elect John Tedesco.
But current members like Board Chairman Kevin Hill are against any delay that would lead to overcrowding at existing schools.
"I just would hate to see a delay," he said. "If a new site is determined to be in the cards, it'll probably mean a two year delay being able to open a new high school in that region."
And then there's the money. The district has invested over $8 million already in the current site. Supporters say that's money wasted if the new high school is built somewhere else.
But critics of the current site prefer another in Rolesville which they say is more accessible, more affordable and mostly already clear. The site already has a ball field and it's also near Hwy 401 right off Louisberry Road.
Both locations are among five a special committee appointed by county commissioners is now reviewing before any more work is done. The new board leadership is hoping they don't select the old site.
"Really, we just felt it wasn't the fiscally responsible thing to do," said Tedesco.